Bed-and-breakfast.it
Top 500 National Top 100 by Region Top 30 by Province Top 10 by City Top 30 by Tourist Destination
City ranking

The 10 Best Properties in San Gimignano

The ranking of the best properties in San Gimignano based on a weighted average of reviews from Bed-and-Breakfast.it, Google and TripAdvisor.
Greve in Chianti Siena Florence Pistoia Campiglia Marittima Capannori San Vincenzo Lucca Pisa Grosseto Livorno Pienza Arezzo Viareggio Manciano
1

Podere Le Retine

San Gimignano (SI)
Holiday House
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.7 (237) Google 10 (119) TripAdvisor 9.8 (125)
9.8 Podere Le Retine - Excellent 481 reviews
Find out more
2

B&B La Cornice

San Gimignano (SI)
Bed & Breakfast
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.6 (35) Google 9.8 (163) TripAdvisor 9.8 (104)
9.8 B&B La Cornice - Excellent 302 reviews
Find out more
3

Tenuta Sovestro - Agriturismo e Winery

San Gimignano (SI)
Country House
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.3 (2) Google 9.8 (135) TripAdvisor 9.8 (35)
9.8 Tenuta Sovestro - Agriturismo e Winery - Very good 172 reviews
Find out more
4

Agriturismo Poggiacolle

San Gimignano (SI)
Country House
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.6 (6) Google 9.6 (156) TripAdvisor 9.6 (505)
9.6 Agriturismo Poggiacolle - Excellent 667 reviews
Find out more
5

La Piazzetta

San Gimignano (SI)
Country House
TripAdvisor 9.8 (105)
9.8 La Piazzetta - Excellent 105 reviews
Find out more
6

Agriturismo Cesani

San Gimignano (SI)
Country House
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.4 (14) Google 9.6 (420) TripAdvisor 9.4 (376)
9.5 Agriturismo Cesani - Very good 810 reviews
Find out more
7

Hotel Sovestro

San Gimignano (SI)
Hotel
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.3 (2) Google 9.4 (599) TripAdvisor 9.4 (926)
9.4 Hotel Sovestro - Very good 1527 reviews
Find out more
8

Villa Alba

San Gimignano (SI)
Bed & Breakfast
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.3 (90) Google 9.4 (90) TripAdvisor 9.4 (285)
9.4 Villa Alba - Very good 465 reviews
Find out more
9

Tenuta Fornacelle

San Gimignano (SI)
Country House
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.3 (1) Google 10 (6) TripAdvisor 9.8 (19)
9.8 Tenuta Fornacelle - Very good 26 reviews
Find out more
10

Agriturismo Fratelli Vagnoni

San Gimignano (SI)
Country House
Bed-and-Breakfast.it 9.3 (10) Google 9.6 (47) TripAdvisor 9.2 (28)
9.4 Agriturismo Fratelli Vagnoni - Very good 85 reviews
Find out more

Top 100 Regions

Top 30 Provinces

Top 10 Cities

Top 30 Tourist sites

Join the most appreciated B&Bs in Italy too.
List your property on Bed-and-Breakfast.it and join the ranking based on travellers' reviews.
List your property
Sources:
Bed-and-Breakfast.it Google TripAdvisor
Updated on 13 April 2026
Methodology: The ranking is compiled considering the properties listed on Bed-and-Breakfast.it and is based on the aggregation of reviews published on Bed-and-Breakfast.it, Google and TripAdvisor. The score takes into account both the average rating and the total number of reviews, rewarding properties with a more solid reputation over time. Only properties with a minimum number of reviews are included, so as to ensure the statistical significance of the result. The ranking is updated periodically. - Learn more

The ranking formula

The position in the ranking is calculated using a weighted Bayesian average, a statistical method widely used to make rankings more reliable.

Unlike simple arithmetic average, this system takes into account not only the average score, but also the number of reviews received. In this way, structures with few reviews but very high votes are not automatically favored over those with many reviews and more established ratings.

Reviews from Google and TripAdvisor are included in the calculation through a conversion from a five-point scale to a ten-point scale.

The formula used is:

Score = (n x R + C x M) / (n + C)

Where:

n = total number of reviews received by the structure
R = weighted average of the structure’s reviews (with Google and TripAdvisor reviews converted to ten-point scale)
M = weighted average of all structures on the platform
C = average number of reviews per structure on the platform